Gallatin County’s Financial Crisis Deepens (Part 2)

August 21, 2026

Share this article

High-Risk Auditee status, $8.5 million over-taxation, and unanswered questions about accountability

Financial crisis deepens in Gallatin County; headline with audit error and corrective actions ongoing on blue background

In Part 1 we reported that Gallatin County received a Disclaimer of Opinion on its FY2023 financial statements — the most severe audit outcome possible — and was designated a High-Risk Auditee. That designation is not symbolic. It is reported to the federal government and is visible to every agency that awards grants or funding to the county. It remains in place until the problems are fixed.


The practical risks are real. A sustained High-Risk Auditee status can affect the county’s bond rating and its ability to receive federal and state funds that support infrastructure, transportation, public health, welfare programs, education-related grants, and Payment in Lieu of Taxes (PILT). If those funds are delayed or reduced, the cost falls on local taxpayers.


The previous hired auditor has already stated it will not begin the FY2024 audit until the long-running cash reconciliation problem is resolved. County Administrator Jim Doar has stated that FY24 is likely to produce another Disclaimer of Opinion. Another Disclaimer for FY2024 or FY2025 would signal a systemic failure rather than an isolated event. The county has already paid $14,565 in state fines for late financial filings.


The $8.5 Million Big Sky Error

On September 30, 2025, the same day the $8.5 million over-taxation of the Big Sky Fire District became public, CFO Justine Swanson resigned. For four years the county had collected approximately $8.5 million more than allowed from residents in that district because of an Excel spreadsheet formula error in the mill levy calculation. The result was a roughly $2.3 million cut to the fire district’s annual budget and a $500,000 deficit. No refund to the overcharged taxpayers has been approved.


  A Commissioner described the CFO’s departure as “related to a mistake.” The Finance Director position was later eliminated, and Deputy County Administrator Cola Rowley, who has since resigned, was added as an authorized bank signatory the day after Swanson’s resignation.
County Administrator Jim Doar has said the Big Sky over-collection and the multi-year cash reconciliation failure are separate issues. Both, however, share a common root: the county’s continued reliance on uncontrolled spreadsheets for critical financial calculations — a weakness auditors first flagged in writing more than a decade ago.


The Core Accountability Question

The county’s own Accounting Manual, in place since 2015, required monthly cash reconciliations and monthly reporting to the Commission. Auditors noted the failure to follow those procedures year after year from 2018 through 2022. Yet there appears to have been little meaningful consequence to their warning.


When written financial controls are ignored for years, when major errors surface only after the damage is done, and when corrective action plans simply say “Ongoing,” taxpayers are right to ask who is being held accountable.


This is Part 2 in our series on Gallatin County’s financial and governance problems. Part 3 will examine the broader pattern of authority shifting away from elected officials and the consequences for lack of transparency.

Recent Posts

Green political poster about Gallatin County Courthouse: “Voters were left out” and “Power moved to hired staff.”
October 12, 2026
Gallatin County commissioners moved power from elected officials to hired staff by resolution. Voters never approved the change.
Sweet deal for Scott MacFarlane? Facilities job opened three days later.
October 9, 2026
Scott MacFarlane left the Gallatin County Commission Feb 17, 2026. Three days later the county posted the Facilities Director job at $112K–$129K. He got it
Who runs Gallatin County elections after 2026?
October 8, 2026
Gallatin County voted 3-0 to take the Election Administrator off the ballot in 2027. Voters will no longer directly hire or fire the person who runs elections.
I-194 won’t stop dark money, vote no
By Roger Koopman • October 1, 2026
Explore how I-194 misleads voters while benefiting out-of-state billionaires. Stay informed on local political rights.
Stylized U.S. Capitol with red and blue paint splashes
September 22, 2026
Montana, Kalispell, and Billings chambers urge a No on I-194: it would silence local businesses while out-of-state billionaires could still spend freely.
Brass scales of justice and a lamp on a desk, with a blurred lawyer writing in the background
September 22, 2026
Most Gallatin County police and sheriffs’ offices have endorsed Jordan Salo for County Attorney. Here’s why they say they won’t back Audrey Cromwell.
Oppose I-133: Don't weaken Montana's Constitution
September 14, 2026
CI-133 Seeks to make placing ballot initiatives on the MT ballot an easier process, therefore circumventing the elected legislature.
Was Gallatin County’s form of government changed without a vote?
September 3, 2026
Part 3: Gallatin County used resolutions to move Treasurer, Administrator, and election duties away from elected officials. The Commission says the form never changed because voters never approved a new label.
Meta logo beside a smartphone facial scan icon and ID card on a dark background
August 31, 2026
Meta’s $17B deal isn’t teen limits. The judgment makes adults surrender privacy, ramps up surveillance and account linking—and Meta waived constitutional challenges.
Cromwell faces criticism over plea deals and rising case dismissals
August 19, 2026
Cromwell's office faces backlash over plea deals & case dismissals in domestic violence cases. Stay informed on local accountability issues.
Show More